I just finished reading a new book THE WOMAN’S HOUR: THE GREAT FIGHT TO WIN THE VOTE by Elaine Weiss.
It’s a lengthy book.
The Susan B. Anthony Amendment is how the 19th Amendment is known – and referred to in the book. Carrie Catt was one of many women working together to win the right to vote for women. She saw it as “really just a clarification, an essential correction, of the Founding Fathers’ damned shortsightedness.” As the book starts, she is on the ground in Tennessee because if the state legislature will ratify it, the amendment will pass.
I wish I could have enjoyed the book.
Even a little.
I did not. It seemed a little too hokey. Oh, here is the section where the modern author works her digs in against Russia, for example. Or it’s not enough that Josephine Pearson be against suffrage, she also has to bemoan the loss of the Confederacy. Especially there, I was looking for how the author knew what Ms. Pearson thought. Of course, she did not know. She just projected.
I have read a lot of wonderful books on women’s progress. Gerda Lerner, for example, remains a standard.
The author, Ms. Weiss, is not academic but maybe she should have been? She covers the terrain as though she is writing a novel – and not a very good novel. She seemed to want to make history come alive more than she wanted to address what took place. She also had a need to dumb everything down to the lowest level. You were good or you were bad – it was cartoonish.
I wanted to like the book but could not. I had no indication, for example, that Ms. Weiss got Emma Goldman’s point regarding suffrage. Ms. Goldman did not believe that voting was the end all and be all. She felt there were important issues to fight for but that voting was not one of them. The suffrage movement, among other things, happened to make a claim that women would clean up politics if they had the right to vote. Ms. Goldman scoffed at the idea (as do I but I am looking at years of proof whereas she was able to see what lay ahead in the distant future). She believed in equality and did not have a lot of tolerance for those who wanted equality some of the time but not others. She wrote a piece on this topic when the Titanic sunk:
Barring all sensational and conflicting reports of the Titanic horrors there are two features which seem to have been overlooked altogether. One is, the part woman has played in the terrible disaster, which to say the least, is in keeping with centuries of her training as a mere female.
With all the claims the present-day woman makes for her equality with man, her great intellectual and emancipatory achievements, she continues to be as weak and dependent, as ready to accept man’s tribute in time of safety and his sacrifice in time of danger, as if she were still in her baby age.
“The men stood aside to let the ladies go first.” What about the ladies? What about their love superior to that of the men? What about their greater goodness? Their demand to equal rights and privileges? Is this to be found only at the polls, or on the statutes? I fear very much that the ladies who have so readily accepted the dictations of the men, who stood by when the men were beaten back from the lifeboats, have demonstrated their utter unfitness and inferiority, not merely to the title of man’s equal, but to her traditionary fame of goodness, love and self-sacrifice.
It is to be hoped that some there were among the steerage victims at least, who preferred death with those they loved to life at the expense of the loved ones.
At another point, she also wrote, “Our modern fetish is universal suffrage. Those who have not yet achieved that goal fight bloody revolutions to obtain it, and those who have enjoyed its reign bring heavy sacrifice to the altar of this omnipotent diety. Woe to the heretic who dare question that divinity!”
She is most famous for her quote, “If voting changed anything, they’d make it illegal.”
Emma Goldman is the real deal.
The suffragette movement was important.
It was not the be all or end all.
I really think the ballot box is highly overrated and the notion that we are changing anything by voting – here in the U.S. – is flat out laughable.
Ms. Weiss appears to have never considered Ms. Goldman’s argument. In fact, she appears to have considered very little in her long career. Possibly, working for the propaganda outlet VOICE OF AMERICA does not improve or foster an analytical skill set. If you have a 9 or 10 year-old grandchild who likes to read, they might enjoy Ms. Weiss’ book. They would probably enjoy a book on Emma Goldman even more or, for that matter, a book about Emma Lazarus. Ms. Lazarus, of course, wrote the poem “The New Colossus.” That is the poem from which we get, “Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, temptest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”
This is C.I.'s "Iraq snapshot:"
Tuesday, March 13, 2018.
Starting in California with Kevin de Leon.
Starting in California with Kevin de Leon.
The largest planned anti-Trump protest today is scheduled for noon at Our Lady of Mt. Carmel Catholic Church in San Ysidro. Speakers will include Sen. Kevin de Leon, Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher and ACLU and labor leaders. bit.ly/2p89FrC
Kevin is running for the US Senate and represents change.
Turning to Iraq . . .
At WAR ON THE ROCKS, War Hawk Douglas Ollivant sees a 'turned corner' -- he's being seeing 'turned corners' -- while walking into one wall after another -- for nearly all 15 years of the ongoing Iraq War:
Iraq continues to move slowly but surely towards recovery. The defeat of ISIL — despite a small insurgent pocket remaining in Kirkuk and Diyala — and the (relative) success of the Kuwait conference give Iraq the tools needed to continue moving forward and begin to solve its myriad of security, economic, and societal problems. Unresolved issues — the integration of Iraq’s battered Sunnis, the relationship with the United States, and the diversification of the national economy, to mention just a few — could lead to a resurgence of the Sunni extremism that saw its latest manifestation in ISIL.
First, however, Iraq must successfully navigate the next election, scheduled for May 12. This election — the second since the end of occupation — presents three key questions for Iraq: First, will Haider al-Abadi be able to retain the prime ministry? Second, will cross-sectarian lists find success? And third, will new voices be able to emerge and take real power? The proliferation of cross-sectarian and pro-reform parties is an encouraging sign, but it remains to be seen whether change has truly come to Iraqi politics at this early stage.
There's so much wrong in the above but what can one expect from the counter-insurgency cheerleader who was wrongly praised and sucked up to by the likes of the breasty Thomas E. Ricks? Douglas still thinks he appears an expert despite his predictions versus the reality of what has actually happened.
In a world with actual consequences, the only thing Douglas would produce at this late date is snorts of derision every time he dared to open his mouth on Iraq.
In the real world, Seth J. Frantzman (JERUSALEM POST) reports:
Poor Dougie. Reality's always had a nasty way of slapping the War Hawks across their lying faces.
Mustafa Mahmoud (NEWS.COM) reports, "Islamic State militants have killed at least 10 people including a local Sunni tribal sheikh in two separate attacks late on Sunday in Iraq's northern provinces of Mosul and Kirkuk, police and local officials say."
“We don’t do body counts” - General Tommy Franks, Commander of US invasion of Iraq, 2002 US officials can’t even be bothered to know how many lives they take in the wake of their imperial catastrophes
But the US didn't get out of the body count business years ago. And it doesn't matter, Abby, what s**t Tommy Franks spewed.
What's Abby referring to? The interview we noted Saturday.
Meanwhile, as the Iraq War is about to enter the 15th year, ALJAZEERA's UP FRONT asks, "Is it time for the US to apologize for invading Iraq?"
From that broadcast.
Mehdi Hasan: Falluja, let's talk Falluja
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: Let's talk Falluja.
Mehdi Hasan: Okay. So in Falluja, how many civilians were killed in Falluja, do you think, by the US forces in 2004?
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: I have no idea.
Mehdi Hasan: Why
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: You should tell me.
Mehdi Hasan: Oh, no. You should tell me. You were in charge of the US military that was doing the killing.
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: I wasn't in charge of the US military.
Mehdi Hasan: Okay, you were a senior commander in the US military that was doing the killing.
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: I was a senior officer in there, okay?
Mehdi Hasan: So how many people died in Falluja?
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: How many people died in combat in Falluja?
Mehdi Hasan: How many civilians were killed by US forces in Falluja?
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: Intentionally?
Mehdi Hasan: No. That's not what I asked. How many were killed?
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: I don't know.
Mehdi Hasan: Do you care?
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: I certainly care. Every loss of civilian life --
Mehdi Hasan: You've had 14 years to find out.
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: Every loss of a civilian life is a tragedy. I accept that.
Mehdi Hasan: So every loss is a tragedy? How many died in Falluja?
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: I don't know.
Mehdi Hasan: Why not? That's a bizarre thing. You go to war. You bomb a city. You don't bother to find out how many people you killed? Intentionally or unintentionally?
Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt: We got out of the body counting business years ago.
He made that claim.
And he wasn't challenged.
He made that claim and he got away with it because so many are so under-informed.
Those who never learn history condemn the rest of us to repeat it. Let's drop back to April 30, 2012:
People who are, for example, 13 may not remember this because they're really too young too. But the US government hid behind the (earlier) pose of 'we don't do body counts' when starting the Iraq War. Of course they did body counts. They did them all along. Three years after the Iraq war started, those who stated 'of course the US is keeping a body count' were backed up with one of the most forgotten stories of the Iraq War.
As with so many of the important stories during the Iraq War, that report came from Knight Ridder. The US government was keeping a body count on Iraqis killed in the violence. They were keeping the count and a military officer freely showed the count to a Knight Ridder reporter.
It shouldn't be hidden history but it is.
Bill Moyers wasn't interested in praising that report when he returned to PBS with Bill Moyers Journal and that was probably due -- Moyers sexism is well known and has been for decades -- to the fact that a woman broke that story: Nancy A. Youssef.
She also wasn't helped out by her outlet. She broke the news for Knight Ridder Newspapers . . . on the last day of the chain's existence. The very next day it was McClatchy Newspapers and McClatchy had little to gain from trumpeting a Knight Ridder report. Things might have been different if the report had been held for one more day allowing it to become McClatchy's first big scoop.
From the June 26, 2006 "Iraq snapshot" (and I'm correcting the spelling of Knight Ridder):
In what might get the most attention today, reporting from Baghdad, Nancy A. Youssef (Knight Ridder) breaks the news that the United States now admits to keeping some figures on Iraqis who have died during the illegal war. Lt. Gen. Peter Chiarelli tells Youssef that "the number of civilian dead and wounded" via US troops "is an important measurement." Chiarelli reveals that "he reviews the figures daily." The US government has denied that any figures were being kept.
I was wrong (not the first time, not the last time), it didn't get the most attention that day. It didn't really get any attention, as we'd note in "2006: The Year of Living Dumbly" -- including it in a long list of Iraq related news that independent media couldn't be counted on to report in the summer of 2006:
Or how about the fact that the US military was keeping a body count on Iraqi deaths? Nancy A. Youssef broke that story, that the US military had been doing that for almost a year, in June. That news lost out to elections . . . in Mexico -- what independent media was all geared up to make the summer story until they dropped everything to head off to the Middle East.
Despite the knowledge that DoD was keeping a count, other outlets ignored Youssef's story and there was never any pressure for the government to supply those figures to the press. So hidden away was Youssef's scoop that weeks later, Phyllis Bennis would go around, weeks after, insisting publicly that US government didn't keep a body count -- like so much of America, even she wads unaware of Nancy Youssef's report. As Phyllis was called out (and not just within this community) and as numbers -- US government numbers -- began to appear in the press, suddenly Phyllis was aware. Basically, it took over a year for her to finally grasp that the voices she was hearing were actual people and not personalities inside her head. That led her to declare in September 2007 on CounterSpin:
Now apparently they're making body counts. So nobody has asked them, "Excuse me, general, when did you start doing body counts?" From the beginning you told us 'We don't do bodycounts.' When did that [tracking the number of Iraqis killed] begin? When do these figures start from?
There was no great mystery, just a failure to pay attention. (In fairness to Phyllis, corporate media wasn't interested in trumpeting Nancy Youssef's scoop and Panhandle Media was working other grudges when Youssef's story broke so they were unable to amplify it.)
Mehdi Hasan's a War Bitch. Those of us who remember him on NPR know that. He's never bothered to learn anything of value and he puts his front paws on Samantha Power's ankles to hump her leg. (Look, he's reTweeted her again, unironically.) He's useless. Which explains how he ends up at THE INTERCEPT. What explains Abby Martin?
I try to be nice but you idiots never know what you're talking about. You've failed to do the basic work required. And then, after months of silence on Iraq, you show up and try to show boat like you're experts when you don't know s**t.
Anyone, in 2018, who wants to do an interview about Iraq body counts but doesn't know what Nancy Youssef reported on the last day of KNIGHT RIDDER, has not done the work required.
How is your stupidity any less damaging than Brig Gen Mark Kimmitt's lies?
I tried to be nice and 'support' Mehdi. Even though he's worthless, hey, it was Iraq. So on Saturday, we promoted the interview -- even though it was worthless as all of Mehdi's work is.
But now Mehdi's being treated like a genius.
Abby, I guess everyone seems like a genius when you don't pay attention to the facts, huh?
Abby types "US officials can't even be bothered to know how many lives they take in the wake of their imperial catastrophes." Actually, Abby, it's you that can't even be bothered to know that the US has kept a body count all along. You should try challenging them to release it. Do something of value regarding Iraq.
Abby's part of a circle jerk and that's what makes her so useless.
Playing footsie with Glenn and Mehdi hasn't helped the Iraqi people, Abby.
What passes for success these days in Iraq?
Nabih Bulos (LOS ANGELES TIMES) reports:
In years past, walls went up to protect against car bombs. Then Shiite Turkmens erected walls to guard against Islamic State after its resurgence in 2014. Now even after the jihadis have been driven out of the city, the walls still stand, and Tuz Khurmatu remains a flash point with an unstable melange of sects and ethnicities. Once united to fight Islamic State, Kurds, Turkmens and Arabs resumed viewing each other with hostility and suspicion.
Keep sniffing that sausage link love, Abby, but don't claim that it's helping the Iraqi people. Maybe you should just go back to ignoring them -- as you've done for months now -- if this is an example of how you 'help' them?
New content at THIRD:
- Truest statement of the Week
- Truest statement of the week II
- A note to our readers
- Editorial: Do the Hillary Whores ever take respons...
- TV: Don't pull at the string
- Black Box Voting moves to the US colony of Iraq
- From The TESR Test Kitchen
- Character study of a relative I can't stand (Dona)...
- Tweet of the week
- SANTA CLARITA DIET
- Sunday Melissa and other bimbos
- To parade or not to parade?
- Little Hollyweird Troll Pretends To Care
- This edition's playlist
The following community sites updated: