With all the human rights abuses that have taken place and are taking place in Falluja, I am reposting the editorial we did at Third:
Editorial: The truth escapes the press (again)
The laughable media narrative of 'liberated' Falluja is both inaccurate and ahistorical.
Remember this, for example:
This persecution -- which is ongoing -- and which is well documented didn't fit last week's media narrative.
Hard to be rah-rah and honest at the same time.
No surprise, forced to choose, the press chose to ditch honesty -- as easily as they discard a dirty undergarment.
If we're supposed to understand what is going on, we need the facts.
The press is very good at acting as an attorney for the US government.
But in carrying out that role, it's become increasingly unable to tell the truth -- full or partial.
Remember this, for example:
Iraq must be a lot safer with Nouri's forcces attacking the people in Falluja.
It's from a May editorial we did entitled "Editorial: The silence cracks " . . .
-
iraq army open gun on kid from sunnis sect in
#falluja@un@hrw@compassiom @tntin1957@bparker001@TonyDuheaume pic.twitter.com/E7UMqXGkfl
شمرية العراق ☪
-
iraq army open gun on kid from sunnis sect in
#falluja@un@hrw@compassiom @tntin1957@bparker001@TonyDuheaume pic.twitter.com/E7UMqXGkfl
It's from a May editorial we did entitled "Editorial: The silence cracks " . . .
A may 2014 editorial.
See the coverage last week was filled with horrifics carried out by the Islamic State.
What the Shi'ite forces were doing?
Barely a murmur.
This despite the long, long history of persecution of the Sunnis.
From that May 2014 editorial:
Yeah, everyone must be sleeping easy now that the 'dangerous' child was taken care of.
Nouri's been killing Iraqi civilians every day and getting away with it for months now.
The US government is giving him even more weapons this despite the fact that he's using them on the Iraqi people.
Thursday, NINA reported his shelling of residential areas of Falluja left 13 civilians dead ("including a woman, three children") and twenty-one more were injured.
That same day, the silence in the US was finally broken.
Janine di Giovanni (Newsweek) reported:
Will others follow suit?
Already AP kind of has. Kind of.
But some western outlet will.
Especially now that Al Jazeera's reporting:
Shelling by the Iraqi army in the city of Fallujah has killed more civilians, hospital sources and witnesses have said, amid allegations that government forces were using barrel bombs in an attempt to drive out anti-government fighters from the area,
The use of barrel bombs in civilian areas is banned under international conventions given their indiscriminate nature.
But Mohammed al-Jumaili, a local journalist, told Al Jazeera that the army has dropped many barrel bombs "targeting mosques, houses and markets" in Fallujah.
And questions will arise.
Such as why did the US government refuse to call out this slaughter?
Nouri's been killing Iraqi civilians every day and getting away with it for months now.
The US government is giving him even more weapons this despite the fact that he's using them on the Iraqi people.
Thursday, NINA reported his shelling of residential areas of Falluja left 13 civilians dead ("including a woman, three children") and twenty-one more were injured.
That same day, the silence in the US was finally broken.
Janine di Giovanni (Newsweek) reported:
“First it was hospitals, then densely populated
civilian areas,” says Erin Evers from Human Rights Watch (HRW) in
Baghdad. “Now it’s neighborhoods where people are just trying to live.”
The
tragedy in Fallujah was barely noticed in the run-up to the Iraqi
parliamentary elections, which took place on April 30, the first
national elections since U.S. troops pulled out of the country in 2011.
No one much paid attention because violence has become a trademark in
this campaign.
Since January, when the Shia-backed
government of Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki began a campaign of
retaliation against the Sunni-backed Islamic State of Iraq and al-Shām,
it is estimated that 4,000 have been killed, or roughly 1,000 a month.
Researchers on the ground say 20 to 30 percent of the dead are children.
Meanwhile, government forces have killed 348, according to Iraq Body
Count.
Will others follow suit?
Already AP kind of has. Kind of.
But some western outlet will.
Especially now that Al Jazeera's reporting:
Shelling by the Iraqi army in the city of Fallujah has killed more civilians, hospital sources and witnesses have said, amid allegations that government forces were using barrel bombs in an attempt to drive out anti-government fighters from the area,
The use of barrel bombs in civilian areas is banned under international conventions given their indiscriminate nature.
But Mohammed al-Jumaili, a local journalist, told Al Jazeera that the army has dropped many barrel bombs "targeting mosques, houses and markets" in Fallujah.
And questions will arise.
Such as why did the US government refuse to call out this slaughter?
This persecution -- which is ongoing -- and which is well documented didn't fit last week's media narrative.
Hard to be rah-rah and honest at the same time.
No surprise, forced to choose, the press chose to ditch honesty -- as easily as they discard a dirty undergarment.
If we're supposed to understand what is going on, we need the facts.
The press is very good at acting as an attorney for the US government.
But in carrying out that role, it's become increasingly unable to tell the truth -- full or partial.
That is the end of the editorial.
We need to think about what is taking place in Falluja.
And how our government has allowed it to take place.
This is C.I.'s "Iraq snapshot:"
Tuesday, June 21, 2016. Chaos and violence continue, Falluja's still
not 'liberated,' Sunnis continue to be persecuted, the White House
continues to avoid attempting a political solution, and much more.
The same old same old continued in Iraq today. The US Defense Dept announced:
Strikes in Iraq
Rocket artillery and bomber, attack, ground-attack, fighter and remotely piloted aircraft conducted 20 strikes in Iraq, coordinated with and in support of the Iraqi government:
Task force officials define a strike as one or more kinetic events that occur in roughly the same geographic location to produce a single, sometimes cumulative, effect. Therefore, officials explained, a single aircraft delivering a single weapon against a lone ISIL vehicle is one strike, but so is multiple aircraft delivering dozens of weapons against buildings, vehicles and weapon systems in a compound, for example, having the cumulative effect of making those targets harder or impossible for ISIL to use. Accordingly, officials said, they do not report the number or type of aircraft employed in a strike, the number of munitions dropped in each strike, or the number of individual munition impact points against a target. Ground-based artillery fired in counterfire or in fire support to maneuver roles is not classified as a strike.
And at the Pentagon today, Pentagon press secretary Peter Cook gave an update on Iraq:
In Fallujah, Iraqi Security Forces, led by the Counter Terrorism Service continue to make progress. About a third of the city has been cleared of ISIL forces, and Iraqi forces continue to advance at a rate of about five to 10 percent of the city per day, being careful to safeguard the lives of civilians and limit property damage to the extent possible.
We continue to provide coalition air support; there have now been 85 strikes over the last four weeks, four in the last 24 hours. We are flying strike missions every day in the fight for Fallujah.
In the north, the Iraqi push towards Qayyarah from multiple axes also continues to make progress. Iraqi forces moving north from Baiji advanced another six kilometers today, overcoming ISIL defenses along the way.
Meanwhile, Iraqi forces moving from the east also continue their push. We are, again, providing significant coalition air support for these efforts as well.
Which is a happy way to spin. AP's a little more blunt as they quote Col Christopher Garver in Baghdad explaining that the 'liberation' of Falluja proclaimed last week hasn't really taken place yet:
Only a third of Fallujah has been “cleared” of Islamic State militants, the U.S.-led coalition said Tuesday, days after the Iraqi government declared victory in the city west of Baghdad, which was held by the extremists for more than two years.
Fighting continues despite the fact that, as Pakistan's THE NEWS INTERNATIONAL notes, "Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi declared victory last week after the national flag was raised above the main government compound."
And not only does the fighting continue, so does the civilians fleeing Falluja. Nick Clark (Great Britain's SOCIALIST WORKER) reports:
Thousands of people are fleeing the Iraqi city of Fallujah despite claims by the Iraqi government to have liberated it from Isis last Friday.
Around 30,000 people were reported to have fled the city last week. The United Nations believes over 80,000 people have left in recent weeks, with refugee camps struggling to cope.
The city was captured by Isis in 2014. Iraqi forces, backed by US and Australian air power, have been waging an assault on Fallujah for several weeks.
The army is still bombarding the city relentlessly despite the tens of thousands of civilians still trapped there.
Karl Schembri of the Norwegian Refugee Council, which runs refugee camps in the area, said, “This comes after months of besiegement.
“They have been eating rotten dates and animal feed.”
A report by Human Rights Watch earlier this month said there were “credible allegations” of abuses by Iraqi forces during the fighting.
These include allegations of summary executions, beatings, disappearances and mutilation of corpses.
A number of people fleeing the city also claim to have been tortured by militias backed by the Iraqi government.
One of them, Abu Muhammad, said, “They would beat us with water pipes. They would take turns to torture us. My hands were tied behind my back, and one of the militants sat on my chest after he got tired of beating me.
“He just threw himself on me. I felt my ribs breaking. I screamed in pain. I spat blood. I asked for water, but I was denied even that.”
And Jonathan Beale (BBC NEWS) reports:
We heard Sunni civilians fleeing the fighting bitterly complain their homes had been targeted by Shia militia helping the Iraqi security forces surround the city.
There is evidence too that men of fighting age have been abused and tortured by some of those same Shia militia.
Aware of the danger of a widening sectarian gulf in taking the city, the US-led coalition has consistently warned the Iraqi government it will withdraw its military support if those Shia forces enter the city itself.
The fighting has already left much of Falluja in ruins and tens of thousands of its citizens displaced.
If the Iraqi government wants to return order, it will have to show quickly it is making efforts to rebuild.
Without homes, hospitals and schools, there will be plenty of lingering resentment.
Any so-called "victory" will be hollow without a dividend for peace.
It's "hollow victory."
Anthony E. Deane (FOREIGN POLICY) explains the reality:
Iraq desperately needs to relearn the lessons from that era to win its war against the Islamic State. Today, Ramadi lies in ruins after a combination of Iraqi forces supported by U.S. airpower, some Sunni tribal fighters, and Shiite Popular Mobilization Forces wrested it from Islamic State control. The city of 400,000 people was destroyed in order to liberate it — and now Fallujah faces a similar fate, as Iraqi forces pushed farther into the city over the weekend. The limited reporting coming out of the area tells a story of atrocities against civilians from both the Islamic State and Shiite militias.
He goes on to cite three lessons learned when he was fighting in Ramadi.
The first one? "Killing off terrorist leaders is only a short-term fix."
And it doesn't address the reason the Islamic State got a foothold in Iraq to begin with.
Shiraz Maher (NEW STATESMAN) explains:
It's a hollow victory at best -- no victory at all at worst.
Didn't have to be that way.
People could have planned.
The US government, the Iraqi government.
They could have worked on a political solution.
Remember that?
US President Barack Obama did.
On June 19, 2014.
But then in August, he began the daily bombings of Iraq and never remembered it again.
John Kerry couldn't help -- he was too busy posing as the Secretary of Defense to do the job he was paid to do: Secretary of State.
Falluja today?
It's not what victory looks like.
Iran Amok (DAILY BEAST) reports:
The same old same old continued in Iraq today. The US Defense Dept announced:
Strikes in Iraq
Rocket artillery and bomber, attack, ground-attack, fighter and remotely piloted aircraft conducted 20 strikes in Iraq, coordinated with and in support of the Iraqi government:
-- Near Baghdadi, two strikes destroyed an ISIL boat and an ISIL mortar system.
-- Near Beiji, two strikes struck
an ISIL tactical unit and destroyed an ISIL fighting position, two ISIL
vehicles, two ISIL vehicle-borne bomb, and an ISIL tunnel system and
denied ISIL access to terrain.
-- Near Fallujah, four strikes
struck two separate ISIL tactical units and destroyed nine ISIL fighting
positions, an ISIL vehicle, an ISIL heavy machine gun, seven ISIL light
machine guns and an ISIL rocket propelled grenade system and denied
ISIL access to terrain.
-- Near Kisik, a strike struck an ISIL tactical unit and destroyed an ISIL assembly area and an ISIL weapons cache.
-- Near Mosul, two strikes struck two separate ISIL tactical units and destroyed an ISIL vehicle and an ISIL tunnel.
-- Near Qayyarah, six strikes
struck an ISIL tactical unit and destroyed three ISIL bunkers, two ISIL
tunnel entrances, an ISIL command-and-control node, two ISIL mortar
systems and six ISIL boats and denied ISIL access to terrain.
-- Near Ramadi, a strike destroyed an ISIL weapons cache.
-- Near Sultan Abdallah, a strike destroyed an ISIL boat.
-- Near Tal Afar, a strike destroyed an ISIL bunker, four ISIL
weapons caches, an ISIL assembly area and an ISIL beddown location.Task force officials define a strike as one or more kinetic events that occur in roughly the same geographic location to produce a single, sometimes cumulative, effect. Therefore, officials explained, a single aircraft delivering a single weapon against a lone ISIL vehicle is one strike, but so is multiple aircraft delivering dozens of weapons against buildings, vehicles and weapon systems in a compound, for example, having the cumulative effect of making those targets harder or impossible for ISIL to use. Accordingly, officials said, they do not report the number or type of aircraft employed in a strike, the number of munitions dropped in each strike, or the number of individual munition impact points against a target. Ground-based artillery fired in counterfire or in fire support to maneuver roles is not classified as a strike.
And at the Pentagon today, Pentagon press secretary Peter Cook gave an update on Iraq:
In Fallujah, Iraqi Security Forces, led by the Counter Terrorism Service continue to make progress. About a third of the city has been cleared of ISIL forces, and Iraqi forces continue to advance at a rate of about five to 10 percent of the city per day, being careful to safeguard the lives of civilians and limit property damage to the extent possible.
We continue to provide coalition air support; there have now been 85 strikes over the last four weeks, four in the last 24 hours. We are flying strike missions every day in the fight for Fallujah.
In the north, the Iraqi push towards Qayyarah from multiple axes also continues to make progress. Iraqi forces moving north from Baiji advanced another six kilometers today, overcoming ISIL defenses along the way.
Meanwhile, Iraqi forces moving from the east also continue their push. We are, again, providing significant coalition air support for these efforts as well.
Which is a happy way to spin. AP's a little more blunt as they quote Col Christopher Garver in Baghdad explaining that the 'liberation' of Falluja proclaimed last week hasn't really taken place yet:
Only a third of Fallujah has been “cleared” of Islamic State militants, the U.S.-led coalition said Tuesday, days after the Iraqi government declared victory in the city west of Baghdad, which was held by the extremists for more than two years.
Fighting continues despite the fact that, as Pakistan's THE NEWS INTERNATIONAL notes, "Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi declared victory last week after the national flag was raised above the main government compound."
And not only does the fighting continue, so does the civilians fleeing Falluja. Nick Clark (Great Britain's SOCIALIST WORKER) reports:
Thousands of people are fleeing the Iraqi city of Fallujah despite claims by the Iraqi government to have liberated it from Isis last Friday.
Around 30,000 people were reported to have fled the city last week. The United Nations believes over 80,000 people have left in recent weeks, with refugee camps struggling to cope.
The city was captured by Isis in 2014. Iraqi forces, backed by US and Australian air power, have been waging an assault on Fallujah for several weeks.
The army is still bombarding the city relentlessly despite the tens of thousands of civilians still trapped there.
Karl Schembri of the Norwegian Refugee Council, which runs refugee camps in the area, said, “This comes after months of besiegement.
“They have been eating rotten dates and animal feed.”
A report by Human Rights Watch earlier this month said there were “credible allegations” of abuses by Iraqi forces during the fighting.
These include allegations of summary executions, beatings, disappearances and mutilation of corpses.
A number of people fleeing the city also claim to have been tortured by militias backed by the Iraqi government.
One of them, Abu Muhammad, said, “They would beat us with water pipes. They would take turns to torture us. My hands were tied behind my back, and one of the militants sat on my chest after he got tired of beating me.
“He just threw himself on me. I felt my ribs breaking. I screamed in pain. I spat blood. I asked for water, but I was denied even that.”
And Jonathan Beale (BBC NEWS) reports:
We heard Sunni civilians fleeing the fighting bitterly complain their homes had been targeted by Shia militia helping the Iraqi security forces surround the city.
There is evidence too that men of fighting age have been abused and tortured by some of those same Shia militia.
Aware of the danger of a widening sectarian gulf in taking the city, the US-led coalition has consistently warned the Iraqi government it will withdraw its military support if those Shia forces enter the city itself.
The fighting has already left much of Falluja in ruins and tens of thousands of its citizens displaced.
If the Iraqi government wants to return order, it will have to show quickly it is making efforts to rebuild.
Without homes, hospitals and schools, there will be plenty of lingering resentment.
Any so-called "victory" will be hollow without a dividend for peace.
It's "hollow victory."
Anthony E. Deane (FOREIGN POLICY) explains the reality:
Iraq desperately needs to relearn the lessons from that era to win its war against the Islamic State. Today, Ramadi lies in ruins after a combination of Iraqi forces supported by U.S. airpower, some Sunni tribal fighters, and Shiite Popular Mobilization Forces wrested it from Islamic State control. The city of 400,000 people was destroyed in order to liberate it — and now Fallujah faces a similar fate, as Iraqi forces pushed farther into the city over the weekend. The limited reporting coming out of the area tells a story of atrocities against civilians from both the Islamic State and Shiite militias.
He goes on to cite three lessons learned when he was fighting in Ramadi.
The first one? "Killing off terrorist leaders is only a short-term fix."
And it doesn't address the reason the Islamic State got a foothold in Iraq to begin with.
Shiraz Maher (NEW STATESMAN) explains:
These latest outrages from incoming
al-Hashd al-Shaabi fighters will only fuel the belief among Sunnis that
they are best served by Sunni administrations – however brutal.
Islamic State has repeatedly invoked the vulnerability of the Sunnis
across the Levant to justify its violence. This is the constituency in
whose name it claims to act and whose interests it claims to defend.
Shortly after IS first captured Mosul, in June 2014, the group released
a video, aimed at Iraqi Sunnis, explaining how both the West and Iraqi
Shias had conspired against them in 2003. The result had been a decline
in Sunni fortunes and increased insecurity as Shia death squads sought
revenge after decades of repression and abuse.
This resonated strongly with Sunnis such as the Albu Mahal and al-Qa’im
tribes, which had supported the US-led “awakening”, a military strategy
initiated in 2005 to encourage Sunni Iraqi tribes to fight against the
insurgency initiated by al-Qaeda. IS captured the heads of those tribes
and forgave them for fighting alongside the West against al-Qaeda in
Iraq. We are not accustomed to seeing videos of IS pardoning captives,
but this was as careful and calculated as any of its ultra-violent
theatre. The exercise was designed to project the group as a bastion of
Sunni honour and security.
That is the story behind so much of IS’s strength today: the fears of
the vulnerable Sunni poor over whom militants govern. Remove that
constituency, and the group would collapse. But the Obama administration
has done little to allay Sunni fears. Rather, it has exacerbated them
by launching air strikes against IS targets in Fallujah, fuelling a
perception that it is working hand-in-glove with Shia militias loyal to
Iran.
It's a hollow victory at best -- no victory at all at worst.
Retweeted 1,330 times
Loveday Morris
In 4 1/2 years covering Syria and Iraq I've never seen conditions this bad. No tents. No water. No words. #Fallujah
Didn't have to be that way.
People could have planned.
The US government, the Iraqi government.
They could have worked on a political solution.
Remember that?
US President Barack Obama did.
On June 19, 2014.
But then in August, he began the daily bombings of Iraq and never remembered it again.
John Kerry couldn't help -- he was too busy posing as the Secretary of Defense to do the job he was paid to do: Secretary of State.
Falluja today?
It's not what victory looks like.
UN Human Rights
#Iraq: Continuing allegations of serious #humanrights violations against civilians fleeing Fallujah, v @ohchr_ar
Iran Amok (DAILY BEAST) reports:
Despite
priding itself on freedom from the sectarianism that has plagued
militias such as Badr, the ICTS seems to be maintaining a strategic,
suspicious relationship with the Hashd.
On June 17, The Daily Beast
witnessed Hadi al-Amiri, leader of Badr, meeting with Abdulwahab
al-Saadi, leader of the operation to retake Fallujah. Several other
leaders from the ICTS also were present.
Earlier that day, al-Saadi had criticized the Hashd, telling The Daily Beast,
“The civilians see the Hashd as militiamen who can’t be controlled,”
yet one of al-Amiri’s bodyguards asserted that the two men meet about
three times a month. The ICTS blocked The Daily Beast and other journalists from the meeting.
The
overt cooperation between Badr, a sectarian militia, and the ICTS, the
one branch of the Armed Forces that has avoided sectarianism, will
further divide Sunnis from the Iraqi government.
Even
the Shia militias in the northern suburbs have tarnished the Iraqi
government’s attempts at a nonsectarian campaign in Fallujah.
Omran
Wali, another Kataib Hezbollah commander in al-Saqlawiyah, claimed, “We
have been welcoming the civilians and treating them very well, bringing
them to the camps for internally displaced people.” But an official
investigation revealed that Shia militias have killed 49 civilians
in the northern suburbs, and another 643 are missing. Iraqis are
discussing rumors that the militias executed those missing in
retaliation for an ISIS massacre at Camp Speicher near Tikrit in 2014.
Again, no real victory. But the White House will throw bombs at Iraq.
And now some more money.
Department of State
.@statedeptspox Kirby announces additional humanitarian assistance for #Iraq
That's US State Dept press spokesperson John Kirby at today's press briefing explaining the money the US is giving:
Speaking of those displaced by conflict, in light of recent events in Iraq and in response to the UN high commissioner for refugees’ recent appeals for emergency needs in Fallujah, the United States is today announcing an additional $20 million in humanitarian aid to UNHCR’s Iraq response. This will be part of a larger package of humanitarian assistance that will be announced later this year. So there’s more aid coming, and I would note that more than 3.3 million Iraqis have been internally displaced since 2014. More are expected to flee in the coming days and weeks. And we’ve seen this, as I said, in Fallujah specifically.
In fact, the UN estimates that about 85,000 people have already fled Fallujah. Yesterday we talked about upwards of 80,000. The UN estimate now is 85,000. The UNHCR has identified camp coordination and camp management as well as protection as its – as its most urgent priorities in the Fallujah response. Other immediate needs include water and sanitation, shelter, and food. Humanitarian agencies are responding to the crisis, but more funding is urgently needed, and we urge other governments to contribute generously to the UN’s Iraq appeals as we have done.
Turning to some of today's other violence . . .
Rami 
In addition, AL BAWABA reports, "At least five Shia militiamen were killed and dozens injured Tuesday by a suicide bombing in northern Iraq, according to an Iraqi police officer."
iraq
the socialist worker
the washington post
loveday morris
